LIVE: The constitutional issues of Special Counsel investigation of Russia, Trump and campaign

Wednesday, 08 June 2016 12:47
Trump's Judge Curiel issue raises important dual citizenship issues
Written by 
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Trump raised an important national issue when he questioned Judge Gonzalo Curiel’s ability to impartially judge the case against Trump University.

Democrats and a few Republicans began shrieking that Trump was a “racist.”

But is asking fair questions about the phenomenon of dual citizenship “racism?”

The official story is that Curiel’s parents were both Mexican nationals.  Curiel’s father came to the United States, apparently illegally, but was somehow able to return to Mexico, marry a Mexican woman there, and both return to the United States, where Curiel was born in Indiana in 1953.

No details are given, however, that would establish whether Curiel’s parents had obtained U.S. citizenship at the time of his birth.

Not that this matters specifically, if Gonzalo Curiel was born in Indiana.  That makes Gonzalo a U.S. citizen in his own right.

But was Gonzalo Curiel also born a citizen of Mexico?

Was Mexican citizenship a right he also acquired at birth through his Mexican parents?

That would make Gonzalo Curiel a dual national. 

So perhaps Donald Trump’s claims are not “racist” and not “crazy,” but point out a much more important factor that is of interest to all Mexicans, whether in the United States or in Mexico.

Mexico actually conducts election campaigns right here in the United States, in order to garner Mexican absentee votes.  And Mexico does not care if its citizens are also citizens of the United States.

The same is true for Filipino communities in the United States. 

Such policies make it difficult, if not impossible, to become, well, to become “American,” and to be loyal to the United States.  And these split loyalties can be communicated to children in a powerful way– so powerful that future generations will not happily enter the immigrant melting pot, but will always have a divided allegiance.

According to the Los Angeles Times, “The U.S. State Department discourages U.S. citizens from retaining or applying for citizenship in another country because ‘dual nationality may limit U.S. government efforts to assist nationals abroad. The country where a dual national is located generally has a stronger claim to that person's allegiance.’ The department also warns that ‘dual citizenship can present a security issue whether to permit access to classified information which affects recruitment, employment and assignments.’ In some cases, dual citizenship could disqualify an applicant for a sensitive position with the CIA or the State Department.”

Some foreign states like Iran do not recognize dual citizenship.  

To Iran, if you are the son of an Iranian father or the wife of an Iranian man, you are automatically an Iranian citizen.  Iran doesn’t care about what citizenship you’ve acquired by birth or otherwise, except that if you claim citizenship of a state hostile to Iran’s government, you may find yourself accused of anti-Iranian espionage and in jail for a long, long time, or else executed.  

This was the story of Jason Resnaian, the California-born son of an Iranian father.  Resnaian knew that he could obtain Iranian citizenship through his father, and he did so in order to obtain journalist’s credentials in Iran. He then proceeded to live and marry in Iran.  But Iran is deeply suspicious of “dual nationals,” and Resnaian and his wife soon found themselves accused of spying.  After a closed-door secret trial, Resnaian was found guilty and ensconced at Evin Prison–Iran’s most notorious.  He was later released as part of an arms deal, along with several others who’d claimed to be Iranian-American “duals.”

Even America’s allies can shift citizenship loyalties.  What is a more powerful psychological influence for many than religion?  Whether by faith or by Zionism or by both, in the late 1960s, some born-in-America American Jews went to Israel and stayed to serve in the Israeli military– at a time when the United States was deeply embroiled in the Vietnam War. This raised many concerns in the U.S. Senate over the problem of dual nationals.  Should U.S. citizens be allowed to reject involvement in U.S. military objectives (i.e. “draft-dodging), while at the same time, these same citizens have independently decided to fight a war in service of another power? 

Donald Trump stirred a storm when he called Judge Curiel a “Mexican,” and suggested that Curiel’s great regard for his Mexican heritage might unfairly influence Curiel.  But Trump may have opened the door for all Americans to ask whether Curiel or other people of Mexican “heritage” put being an American first, over being a “Mexican-American.”  Curiel’s membership in the “La Raza” California Lawyers Association raises questions that many will now want fully answered.  

And their answers may surprise us.

But what will truly save America is about being able to ask the hard questions. 

Sarah Whalen

sarahw2Sarah Whalen is a university journalism instructor, attorney and author.

Login to post comments
  • Cat Fights on the Hot Cement Confederate New Orleans statues
  • Ex-Saints, Bears, Bills, NFL Exec, Jim W. Miller discusses NFL Draft tomorrow
  • Trump's new plan; Curtains on tax returns release; 40% say Trump-Russia; Probing Obama admin
  • Watch Louisiana Governor Edwards talk about CAT Tax failure

catRarely, have I seen few issues that have generated as much raw heat, tension, and passion than the Confederate monuments controversy. 

Just as existed during the real civil war, where brothers battled brothers, social media is the battleground, particularly Facebook, pitting friend against friend.

On one side of the tense divide, there are those who are protecting the New Orleans civil war era monuments.  Burnt in effigy, forever, is the symbol of Mayor Mitch Landrieu for up-ending what the monument protectors consider to be the loving civil society of New Orleans.

Lately, events have turned somewhat militaristic.

Some protectors of the Confederate monuments have been staying vigilant, in person and online, even surveilling during the wee hours of the morning, waiting for the next Mayor Landrieu attack. On Sunday morning, with protections of snipers, masked workers and a dumbstruck audience, the worst of all of the monuments was cut and carried., the Liberty Monument. 

Read More

miller nfl live2 5It’s D-Day or Draft Day tomorrow in the NFL.

More specifically, Thursday represents the first day of the NFL draft 2017.

Read More


trump curtainsThe major President Trump news of the day focuses upon taxes, not only the tax cuts he is proposing but his own taxes, which he obviously, refuses to unveil.


Read More

edwards play money 1

At a press conference today, Louisiana Governor John Bel Edwards said the CAT Tax did not pass the House Ways and Means Committee.  The Governor, in addressing the media said that "the fate of that bill was decided long before we unveiled it".

Read More

BB Menu


Sen. Appel talks budget, economy


Dead Pelican

Optimized-DeadPelican2 1 1