Wednesday, 29 July 2015 12:41
Why Louisiana GOP chose Jeff Landry over incumbent Buddy Caldwell
Written by 

lagop logo new 600 stripesIt’s not that it’s rare; it’s that it’s never happened before. Until the Louisiana Republican Party endorsed former Rep. Jeff Landry against incumbent Atty. Gen. Buddy Caldwell for the latter’s job this fall, no statewide office incumbent ever elected as a Republican had faced a challenger endorsed by the party. And it had good reason to make this historical move.


Of course, having been no statewide office GOP incumbents in the post-Reconstruction era until former Gov. Dave Treen’s win in 1979, it’s only been in the 21st century where there has been any real opportunities to have Republicans elected to these offices, much less run for reelection and have a strong challenger from the party emerge. The only other time this has happened was in 2011 when Lt. Gov. Jay Dardenne fended off former Plaquemines Parish Pres. Billy Nungesser, with the party issuing no endorsement on that occasion.

Nonetheless, to pick a challenger of the party over one of its incumbents should raise eyebrows regardless of how many opportunities have existed for that to happen. Yet if you happen to be a conservative, there’s no real mystery to why it happened this time.

In Landry’s one term in Congress, he compiled a solid, even exceptional, conservative record. Caldwell ran as a Democrat to win in 2007, but as a Republican for reelection in 2011. In both instances, he followed the standard playbook successful Democrats have used since the tide began turning against them this millennium – appear to oppose corruption and promote a conservative record on social issues in the hopes it overshadows liberalism on everything else.

So in establishing credentials to win the support of his new party’s identifiers, Caldwell can point to some in these realms. He fought a backdoor method to force Louisiana to accept same sex marriage, and also the front door attempt. He also went after alleged favoritism in the state handing out a huge contract. He even showed his office’s opposition to the excesses of the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act by suing to overturn parts of it on two occasions.

But in that instance, his ideological slip showed when he expressed more confidence in government running insurance markets than the private sector. And on a number of other issues dealing with the marketplace and commerce, he has shown a definite preference against commercial interests, if not conceptualizing them as piñatas to burst with a good whack, while trying to create arrangements (and attempting to expand these) to steer more state funds for this work to trial lawyers.

Most notoriously, he ended up on the losing side of a case against a drug manufacturer brought on the basis of jackpot justice because he wanted to increase the potential size of the award, and another where he allowed to go forward a wretchedly bad contingency contract by a local government that tried with outside counsel to sue oil companies for environmental damage that got laughed out of court. Then there’s Caldwell’s refusal to back the rule of law when necessary and politicization of the office, providing much concern for the conservatives that make up the majority of state GOP leaders.

Defenders of Caldwell, relative to Landry (there is another minor candidate in the contest with prosecutorial experience), may point to his having been a district attorney prior to becoming attorney general, while Landry has no prosecutorial experience (a point Caldwell’s campaign made in response to the announcement), but that background isn’t an important attribute of an attorney general. They may prosecute only in civil matters, or when invited by district attorneys or the judiciary, and they have plenty of assistants who can do that. More important is the judgment and temperament of the officer, in choosing which civil cases the state ought to bring and in issuing opinions when requested on the law (unless these are overridden by administrative or statutory law). Landry’s limited government views that stress enforcing existing law as opposed to using the office simultaneously to shake down business and enrich trial lawyers seems much more agreeable to Republicans.

It was poor judgment in picking cases to try that doomed Caldwell’s predecessor in his reelection bid, but Caldwell’s choices with these may be even more egregiously bad. Undoubtedly this prompted the Louisiana GOP to take its unprecedented step, and increases Landry’s decent chance to knock him off.

Jeffrey Sadow

Jeffrey Sadow is an associate professor of political science at Louisiana State University in Shreveport.   He writes a daily conservative blog called Between The Lines

Login to post comments
  • A July 4th Fact of Facts: America is Land of Immigrants
  • Poll: Trump strong on jobs, weak on tweets, viewed as reckless, thin-skinned, sexist
  • President Trump, It doesn't feel like Independence Day
  • YIPPIE! The naked truth about free speech, cherished especially on Independence Day

mass2On July 4, 1778, George Washington doubled liquor rations for the soldiers quartered in Princeton, NJ, as a way to celebrate Independence Day. It’s fitting, therefore, that the Fourth of July is America's top-selling beer holiday, according to the Beer Institute. It estimated, in 2013, that sales of beer on the 4th could total $1 billion, doubtlessly higher today. “In moderation,” claims a CA brewery investor, Grover McKean, “beer is tasty and healthy.” Who could disagree?

Read More

joe mikaAs Donald Trump faces the top world leaders this week, including a face-time with Vladimir Putin, and as his healthcare proposals face an uphill climb, his poll numbers for how the nation views him could be better.

According to a morning Consult/Politico poll released Wednesday morning, his tweets, including that against MSNBC's Mika Brzezinski, and his personality are not helping him, at all.

Read More

indy dayII know the calendar says we are approaching the 4th of July, but, it just doesn’t feel like Independence Day.

Perhaps it should.  It’s hot as heck.  The airlines have been packed. The hot dogs are ready for grilling.  The umps are saying, "play ball". The patriotic activities are scheduled. The fireworks are ready-for-blasting. 

Yet, it just doesn’t feel like independence day.

Read More

bill rights2To President Thomas Jefferson, July 4th celebrated more than the signing of the Declaration of Independence. He thought it was a link to the future. The message prominent colonists sent to King George III led to the Constitution and the Bill of Rights, the initial and most prominent feature of which is the First Amendment that guarantees free speech. It’s part of the country’s fundamental essence that each man and woman can say what they feel about government, or anything else, proving President Donald Trump needs some civics lessons.

Read More


Dead Pelican

Optimized-DeadPelican2 1 1