After watching the video, click here
Thursday, 20 September 2012 06:53
Jindal dissenters, protesters will not stop Louisiana healthcare, education reform
Written by 

GreensteinFeel better now, after the three-hour tantrum about the closing of the Southeast State Hospital? Feel better now, after the six-month tantrum about education reform? I hope so, because neither changes the fact of the rectitude both of the closure and reform.

If modern liberalism were in charge in most respects of public policy-making in Louisiana, these actions of a meeting to protest the closure and of a recall petition directed at Gov. Bobby Jindal would resonate perfectly with that ideology’s dependence upon emotion and assertion of feelings to formulate policy, with inconvenient facts shoved aside in a blizzard of illogic. But it isn’t, and the facts remain.



Louisiana as a state, both in terms of public and private mental health beds per capita, is in the top quarter of states, and plenty of beds exist in the Regions 1 and 9 that had been served by the hospital. Some family members will have to travel longer distances to visit patients, but it’s not the state’s job to give them curb service, only to do the best it can (often for free) to treat the afflicted. Many families and patients also have the option of private and non-profit providers in the area.

Department of Health and Hospitals Secretary Bruce Greenstein hit the nail on the head when he said, “too many of our resources are invested in large public institutions. That is not the best model of care for our residents and it's not in the best interest of taxpayers. Rather, the Department will build partnerships with community providers and target improved models of care focused on smaller residential settings, de-emphasizing the role of large public institutions and making more efficient use of taxpayer dollars.” Compare this attitude to people on the state payroll both elected and not, bawling about the loss of jobs at the hospital, where they could use reminding that it is policy of the state to get treatment to individuals who need it regardless of the origin of the provider, not that the state provide direct employment.

Job reductions also, as well as a demand for better service, lay at the heart of the recall effort against Jindal. The reforms stress outcomes that promise to eject teachers who insufficiently know their subjects and/or don’t convey the knowledge well out of the system who heretofore have burrowed into it. These also challenge teachers to increase utilization of their own abilities, as to demand more of students always demands more of the teacher. Some too comfortable and complicit in the old underperforming system, wont to argue whatever ails elementary and secondary education is so out of their hands that only large infusions of money will solve for it, decided the best way to hang onto power and privilege was to initiate a recall against Jindal, and then added a few state legislators for good measure.

With the movement illegally shrouded in secrecy, from what we can tell the deadline at least for the Jindal petition was yesterday. That the state’s media did not have filed a story today on the quest indicates that educator-organizers fell short – probably miserably so – of the several hundred thousand signatures needed to launch an election. As of this morning, the website, which had all of the recall efforts attached to it, returned only an “under construction” advisory. Thus with a whimper goes away all of the self-righteous bluster of a small handful of individuals profoundly out of step and out of touch with the people and their children’s needs.

At least a few of those protesting the hospital shuttering are working on the notion that Greenstein suggested by exploring partnerships with non-government providers to keep at least part of the facility open – which of course begs the question why this wasn’t done beforehand, if service provision most efficient for the taxpayer was utmost in their minds. Maybe the recall organizers now will emulate and decide to renounce being part of the problem and become part of the solution.

(Photo: Bruce Greenstein)


 {jvotesystem poll=|7|}



  Want more Louisiana news?               

Louisiana News

Louisiana Politics

Louisiana Business

Louisiana Government

 Baton Rouge News

Lafayette News

Shreveport  News

New Orleans News



Signup for Our Newsletter


Scan the QR Code above using your smartphone to signup for our newsletter.

Join Our Email List



Jeffrey Sadow

Jeffrey Sadow is an associate professor of political science at Louisiana State University in Shreveport.   He writes a daily conservative blog called Between The Lines

Login to post comments
Powered By JFBConnect
  • Deja vu for Louisiana high-speed a Internet Broadband project, once again
  • Republicans Gatti, Crews vie for Louisiana House to replace now-Congressman Mike Johnson
  • Retiring Louisiana State Police Chief Edmonson retirement $ back in news
  • Trump, Ryan going to BAT for tax reform, economic growth

jindal broadbandIt’s déjà vu all over again for a broadband access project in Louisiana that saw the same mistakes repeated, leading to its demise both times.

Read More

lou gehrig burnettby Lou Gehrig Burnett, Publisher of Fax-Net

   Raymond Crews and Robbie Gatti are headed to a runoff in state House District 8 on April 29 to fill  the seat left vacant when Mike Johnson was elected  to Congress.  Both are Republicans.
    Crews came in first with 41% of the vote, followed by Gatti with 37%..  Two other candidates in the race were Duke Lowrie, who finished with 16%, and Patrick Harrington, who had 6%.

Read More

edmonson2by Tom Aswell, Publisher of Louisiana Voice

It must be nice when you can get the rules written just for you.

There must come a time when even the most disinterested, blasé, apolitical person living has to look up from whatever else occupies his interest and say, “Wait a damned minute. This just ain’t right and we’re not gonna do it.”

Read More

trump greatIt has been over three decades since our country’s last major tax reform was passed during the Reagan administration. Since that time, America has increased tax rates on businesses and individuals and become less competitive. 

Read More



Trump Talk: Ryancare, Russia, Investigations, Travel ban--with Jeff Crouere

Dead Pelican

Optimized-DeadPelican2 1 1