Friday, 18 January 2013 15:08

Rove and out-of-touch GOP needs reality check and courage

Written by
Rate this item
(0 votes)

Right-wing-mediaWhere does the Republican Party go from here? Are major changes in both direction and philosophy necessary?

Not a problem say some party operatives.  Don’t overreact to the latest defeat.  The Democrats will screw things up and swing voters will be rushing back to the GOP column in the next election-right?

Senior Bush adviser Karl Rowe emulates this “just stay the course” line of thinking.  He was in my hometown of Baton Rouge last week speaking to a statewide business group. Rowe espoused the institutional party line that there really is no major problem.  The big challenge is mechanical.  Democrats just did a better job of getting out the vote according to his way of analyzing.  The candidate himself was a hard sell, and the campaign technology was weak.  Oh, and we forgot about the Latinos.  But all this, according to Rove, can be fixed in the future.

If only it were that simple.  Rowe and his cohorts who thing along similar lines, are not looking at history.  You have to go back to 1988 to find a Republican candidate for president who was able to garner more than half the popular vote.  In five of the past six elections, Democrats have out polled Republicans.

Republicans are bragging about holding on the control of the House of Representatives.  But although Democrats won fewer congressional districts, they received over a million more votes.

What should be particularly troubling to Republicans is lack of interest, even disdain, for the fastest growing electoral constituencies.  Three-quarters of Asians and Hispanics ignored the GOP message.  African-Americans overwhelming rejected the Republican ticket.  In central Philadelphia, among 59 districts that were heavily African-American, Romney did not get a vote.  Not one!  The totals were: Obama 19,604, Romney 0.

The story was similar with most other constituencies.  The Democrats won young voters by 67%, unmarried women by 67% and carried women overall by 55/44%.  The last ditch constituency for Republicans reflects their leadership in Washington-old white guys. Republicans were watching “Madmen,” while Democrats were tuned to “Modern Family.” 

To refute Karl Rowe, he and similiar voices in the party have failed to realize they have an identity problem, and to many observers, have lost their way.  And in doing so, Middle America has drifted away for a comfort level with the GOP.  The country has changed demographically.  But the party of Jefferson and Lincoln is still stuck in a rut.

Both national political parties have room for growth, and in the past, have espoused a "big tent" philosophy, where, within reason, there was room for divergent views.  But there is a growing perception that the GOP is gravitating towards more extreme positions on the right that have become a turnoff for millions of more centralist thinking Republicans.  The rhetoric has gotten stale.  Birtherism, Obama is a racist.  The shrill voices of survivalists who are hunkering down, building fences, issued a call to arms with rhetoric that is too extreme for many more moderate Republicans.  Party leaders seem to be listening to the loudest voices. And too often, these voices are on the fringe of the GOP.  To some observers, there has been confected a Thelma and Louise strategy of taking the party over the cliff.

You wonder what happened to the moderates in the Republican Party.  It’s simple.  The John McCains and the Lindsay Grahams got scared and moved to the right.  Pragmatism went out the window. Party leaders keep talking about the leadership of Ronald Reagan.  But the Gipper was pragmatic, raised taxes when necessary and came out strongly against assault weapons.

How was Obama able to do so well in traditionally Republican western states?  The President won in Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico and lost by close margins across the west where Republicans generally run up big majorities.  The simple fact is that the GOP has moved away from Western conservatism.  Out west, there is a libertarian streak that wants the government to stay out of an individual’s person life.  And that use to be the case with the Republican Party.  Too often, modern day conservatives seem too obsessed with what goes on inside someone’s home, and seem unbothered by what used to be constitutional protections.

The conservative “New American” magazine recently released their annual “Freedom Index,” that reviewed congressional votes on limited government, privacy protections, defending personal freedoms and fiscal responsibility. The Senate average of Republicans was a pathetic 47%.

If there is a new brand of leadership that hopes to emerge in the Republican Party, they need to tell voters what there are for.  We are bombarded with all the things Republicans are against.  Where is the vision; the promise for the future?  We live in a different age and real Americans have a changing set of realities.

One of the Republican Party’s “best and brightest” was Congressman Jack Kemp.  He made the point that: “You don’t beat a thesis with an antithesis. You beat it with a better thesis.” 

Sure there are a number of bold ideas out there that are consistent with conservative, libertarian values.  A good bit of courage is involved.  The angry grassroots may be initially not all that receptive. But isn’t that what leadership is all about?

Denial and anger is not going to put the GOP on the path to victory.  It’s more, much more than a shift in tactics.  There is a shift in culture required.  Maybe an attitude adjustment.  There is a way for Republicans to come out of the wasteland.  Finding that way will require the will, strong backbone, spunk, guts and tenacity.  Who’s there to pick up the mantel and meet the challenge?


“Don’t find fault, find a remedy.”

Henry Ford

Peace and Justice

Jim Brown

Jim Brown’s syndicated column appears each week in numerous newspapers throughout the nation and on websites worldwide.  You can read all his past columns and see continuing updates at  You can also hear Jim’s nationally syndicated radio show each Sunday morning from 9 am till 11:00 am, central time, on the Genesis Radio Network, with a live stream at

{jvotesystem poll=|43|}


Jim Brown

Jim Brown is a Louisiana legislator, Secretary of State and Insurance Commissioner. | This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.

Dead Pelican

Optimized-DeadPelican2 1 1